andrei | January 26, 2026 | Car Accidents
What to Do When the Other Driver Lies About the Car Accident
Few things are more frustrating after a car accident than realizing the other driver is not telling the truth. You may know exactly what happened, yet their version of events shifts blame onto you, minimizes their conduct, or ignores key facts entirely. Unfortunately, this situation is common in Texas car accident claims, especially when injuries and insurance money are involved.
When a driver lies, the consequences can extend far beyond irritation. False statements can influence police reports, insurance investigations, and even settlement negotiations. Knowing how to respond, and how to protect yourself legally, can be the difference between a denied claim and a fair recovery.
If you’ve been in a car accident and the other driver lies about it or tries to blame it on you, call The Crash Team. Our Texas car accident lawyers are available 24/7 at 713-300-0000, or you can contact us online for a free consultation.
Why Drivers Lie After Car Accidents in Texas
Drivers rarely lie without a motive. In Texas, fault directly affects financial responsibility, so even small shifts in blame can have significant consequences. A driver who believes they will be held responsible for medical bills, vehicle repairs, or a lawsuit may see dishonesty as a shortcut to avoiding accountability.
Texas follows a modified comparative fault rule. If you are found more than 50 percent at fault, you recover nothing. Even partial fault reduces compensation proportionally. This legal framework creates pressure for drivers to distort facts, exaggerate your actions, or downplay their own.
Common reasons drivers lie include fear of higher insurance premiums, concerns about traffic citations, or prior driving issues such as distracted driving or intoxication. In commercial vehicle cases or rideshare accidents, the stakes can be even higher, as employers and corporate insurers may be involved. Understanding these motivations helps explain why false narratives appear so quickly after a crash.
What to Do Immediately When You Suspect the Other Driver Is Lying
Your actions in the moments following a crash matter. Even before lawyers or insurers become involved, early steps can preserve evidence and limit the impact of false statements.
At the scene, focus on safety first, then documentation. Avoid confrontations; arguing rarely helps and can complicate matters later. Instead, concentrate on creating a clear factual record.
Helpful steps include:
- Calling law enforcement and requesting a formal accident report
- Taking photos of vehicle damage, road conditions, and traffic signs
- Recording short videos that show the scene from multiple angles
- Collecting contact information from witnesses
- Seeking medical attention, even if injuries seem minor
These actions serve two purposes. They protect your health and create objective evidence. When stories conflict, photos, videos, and witness accounts often carry more weight than verbal claims made under stress.
How Police Reports and Insurance Statements Can Be Affected by Lies
Police officers typically arrive after the crash has occurred. They rely on physical evidence, witness statements, and what drivers tell them. If the other driver lies confidently or repeatedly, those statements may influence the initial report, even if they are inaccurate.
Insurance companies then rely heavily on that report during claim evaluations. Adjusters look for consistency and may treat conflicting accounts as grounds to deny or delay payment. This creates a cause-and-effect problem; a single false statement can snowball into prolonged disputes and financial strain.
It is important to understand that police reports are not final determinations of civil liability in Texas. They are pieces of evidence, not verdicts. Still, correcting or countering a misleading narrative becomes harder with time. Prompt legal guidance can prevent early inaccuracies from becoming entrenched obstacles.
Gathering Evidence to Expose False Statements
Evidence is the most effective antidote to dishonesty. When facts are documented clearly, lies tend to unravel. Texas courts and insurers prioritize objective proof over subjective recollections.
Key forms of evidence include:
- Dashcam footage from your vehicle or nearby cars
- Surveillance video from businesses or traffic cameras
- Vehicle data showing speed or braking patterns
- Medical records linking injuries to the crash
- Independent witness testimony
For example, a driver may claim you ran a red light. Traffic camera footage or witness accounts can directly contradict that statement. In rear-end collisions, vehicle damage patterns often tell a different story than verbal blame-shifting.
This evidence also affects settlement versus trial decisions. Strong documentation may push insurers to settle rather than risk a courtroom loss. Weak or missing evidence often emboldens them to deny claims.
Dealing With Insurance Companies When the Truth Is Contested
Insurance companies are not neutral referees. Their goal is to limit payouts. When stories conflict, adjusters may delay decisions, request repeated statements, or pressure you into accepting partial fault.
You should be cautious when speaking with insurers, especially the other driver’s carrier. Casual comments can be taken out of context or used to support false claims. Providing recorded statements without legal advice is risky, particularly in contested cases.
A typical insurance dispute follows a pattern: investigation, negotiation, and potential litigation. When the other driver lies, the investigation phase becomes more adversarial. Delays often occur because insurers wait for additional evidence or hope claimants give up. Understanding this process helps set expectations and reinforces why legal representation matters early.
When a Lawyer Becomes Essential in a Lying Driver Case
Not every accident requires an attorney, but cases involving dishonesty often do. When facts are disputed, legal strategy matters as much as evidence. Attorneys know how to frame contradictions, highlight inconsistencies, and apply Texas negligence law effectively.
A lawyer can:
- Conduct an independent investigation
- Communicate with insurers on your behalf
- Preserve and subpoena critical evidence
- Prepare the case for trial if negotiations fail
At The CrashTeam, attorneys Aaron Galvan and Breanne Galvan approach these cases with a litigation mindset. Insurers are less likely to rely on false narratives when they know a firm is prepared to take a case to court. This leverage often shifts negotiations and protects clients from unfair fault assignments.
The Risks of Doing Nothing When the Other Driver Lies
Ignoring lies does not make them disappear. In fact, silence can be interpreted as acceptance. When false claims go unchallenged, they can harden into the official version of events.
The risks include reduced settlement offers, denied claims, and prolonged legal battles. In severe injury cases, such as traumatic brain injuries or wrongful death, these consequences can be devastating. Medical bills accumulate, income is lost, and families face unnecessary stress.
Texas has a two-year statute of limitations for most personal injury claims. Waiting too long can limit options, regardless of how dishonest the other driver was. Timely action preserves rights and strengthens credibility.
When the Other Driver Lies, The Crash Team Can Help!
When the other driver lies about a car accident, you deserve more than frustration; you deserve a clear strategy. The Crash Team helps clients in Sugar Land and across Texas confront false narratives with evidence, experience, and persistence. From early investigations to courtroom advocacy, their team focuses on protecting your version of events.
Insurance companies often test how far they can push when stories conflict. Having proven injury attorneys with serious litigation experience changes that dynamic. The Crash Team is known for standing firm, challenging dishonesty, and pursuing fair outcomes for injured clients.
If you believe the truth is being twisted in your case, now is the time to act. A conversation with The Crash Team can help you understand your options and take control of the situation before false claims cause lasting damage.
